Review – Train Line 45 New HSB Passenger Car

Background

Train Line 45 has offered Harz passenger cars for almost 15 years, and ever since their introduction they have been very popular amongst HSB enthusiasts – for good reason.

First of all, the product itself. The cars are reasonably accurate to the prototype and come in 6, 7 and 8 window versions, so prototypical train compositions are possible. They’re nicely painted in the HSB dark red and beige scheme, and TL45 also offers advertising liveries such as “Schierker Feuerstein”, “Faust” and “Hasseröder” for extra diversity.

Secondly, there’s no real competition. TL45 announced their cars in the correct HSB dark red while LGB’s were much too bright. LGB later corrected the color, but that was too little too late: their cars are still 6 window only, making any prototypical HSB train impossible.

Finally, TL45 keeps all versions, paint schemes and even different road numbers in stock. LGB’s HSB cars aren’t available at all today, typical of Märklin product strategy where a production runs only every now and then.

TL45’s HSB cars aren’t without criticism though. The balcony details are either incorrect or incomplete, though overall they capture the look of the real thing. The largest flaw were the windows: simply too large vertically, with an understated black window frame and a silver section meant to resemble the prototype’s tilt window that just didn’t work visually.

So, enter TL45’s updated HSB passenger car. The 6 window version arrived first last year with two road numbers, and since then the redesigned 7 window car has joined the range with two road numbers of its own, while the 6 window car has gained two additional numbers as well.

New HSB Passenger Car

Here’s how the new car looks fresh out of the box, before applying any of the supplied detail parts.

Train Line New HSB Passenger Car

The detail parts come in a small plastic bag: two coupler hooks, two coupler bolts, and two brake cranks. New for this car are the four yellow lifting hooks and the four handrails that now complete the railing on the balcony.

Train Line New HSB Passenger Car

Here’s how it looks with them applied – honestly a great improvement.

Train Line New HSB Passenger Car

And here’s a comparison between the old car (left) and the new one (right). The difference in window size is immediately evident, and it just looks so much better now.

Note: the coupler hooks and brake cranks are not applied to either car.

Train Line New HSB Passenger Car

Now for the less good news, starting mild and getting worse.

You may have spotted it in the first picture, but this little plastic curl was easily cut off — no issue.

Train Line New HSB Passenger Car

A bit of paint or glue stuck to the right side of the window.

Train Line New HSB Passenger Car

Many scratches on the windows in this particular case.

Train Line New HSB Passenger Car

Honestly terrible paint work. A quick wipe didn’t help, so I’ll have to see how to fix this, if it’s possible at all.

Train Line New HSB Passenger Car

Finally, I’m not sure whether the beige window inserts are push fitted or glued in place, but one of them was only held at a single corner.

Final Thoughts

Overall, Train Line 45 made a fantastic decision to invest in new tooling for the HSB cars. They look great. Now we’re just waiting for the 8 window version to join the range.

I would love to recommend Train Line 45 products without hesitation, but I cannot. I’ve bought many of their products over the years and reviewed some of them here on Large Scale Insider (or previously on G Scale News), and I often draw the same conclusion: the fact these products exist is great, and TL45 shows real craftsmanship and a determination to battle the established brands. But too often I’m left unsatisfied by small or larger issues that good quality checks would have caught easily.

So my advice is to never buy them online. Buy them in a physical store and unbox them before you leave. Check the paint, check the lettering, and check that all supplied parts are there. Otherwise you just end up frustrated, and shipping products back and forth doesn’t do you, the seller, or the planet any favors.

One last note: the first two cars released in 2025 came with the yellow hooks and handrails as well, but 3D printed. I saw them in person and they didn’t look great. I spoke to Train Line, who said molded parts would follow, and the 2026 car I just reviewed indeed has them – they look a lot better. Unfortunately this complicates both the new and used markets, as it’s hard to tell from a picture alone which parts you’re getting.

Disclaimer

Personal Purchase: This product was purchased by me from the official Train Line 45 webshop at a regular consumer price. All opinions expressed are my own.

Product Info

Reviewed:

  • Train Line 45 3230722 HSB Passenger Car, 6 Window, 900-486 (new 2026)

Also Available:

  • Train Line 45 3230721 HSB Passenger Car, 6 Window, 900-478 (launch version 2025)
  • Train Line 45 3230723 HSB Passenger Car, 6 Window, 900-441 (launch version 2025)
  • Train Line 45 3230720 HSB Passenger Car, 6 Window, 900-521 (new 2026)
  • Train Line 45 3230770 HSB Passenger Car, 7 Window, 900-472 (new 2026)
  • Train Line 45 3230771 HSB Passenger Car, 7 Window, 900-475 (new 2026)
  • Train Line 45 3230776 HSB Passenger Car, 7 Window, “Schierker Feuerstein”, 900-473 (new 2026)

Pricing (MSRP 2026):

  • 6 Window: € 249,00
  • 7 Window: € 259,00