Review – PIKO G Scale Track Geometry in Practice – It’s a LIE!

PIKO’s G scale track system is a clever system of four different curve radii and some standardized straight track lengths. This page goes more into detail: G Scale Track Geometry Series – PIKO. That all sounds promising in theory.

However, I wanted to build a little test track in the basement to test some rolling stock for Large Scale Insider and for some other general testing of services I perform for my clients. I had a combination of PIKO R1, R3 and R5 curves in place, but I wanted to add a PIKO R5 switch into the mix as I wanted to test the capacities of some locos over the ‘dead’ plastic frog at crawl speed. However, I expected a drop-in replacement, but the surrounding track didn’t line up. I then tested the other radii as well, and it got even more confusing…


PIKO R1 Curves & Switches

Theory:

  • PIKO R1 Curve (#35211) = 30 degree angle (12 pcs make a circle)
  • PIKO R1 Switch (#35220 / #35221) = 30 degree angle
  • Expectation: R1 Switch exactly matches 1 PIKO R1 curve

Reality = Perfect match! ✅

PIKO G Scale Track Geometry Switch R1

PIKO G Scale Track Geometry Switch R1


PIKO R3 Curves & Switches

Theory:

  • PIKO Standard R3 Curve (#35213) = 30 degree angle (12 pcs make a circle)
  • PIKO Short R3 Curve (#35214) = 7,5 degree angle
  • PIKO R3 Switch (#35228 / #35229) = 22,5 degree angle + short R3 curve 7,5 degree
  • Expectation: The R3 Switch (22,5 degree) with the supplied short R3 curve piece (7,5 degree) totals 30 degree, thus matching 1 standard R3 curve.

Reality = Not matching ⚠️, the R3 Switch extends beyond the R3 Curve.

PIKO G Scale Track Geometry Switch R3

PIKO G Scale Track Geometry Switch R3


PIKO R5 Curves & Switches

Theory:

  • PIKO Standard R5 Curve (#35215) = 15 degree angle (24 pcs make a circle)
  • PIKO Short R5 Curve (#35216) = 7,5 degree angle
  • PIKO R5 Switch (#35222 / #35223) = 22,5 degree angle + short R5 curve 7,5 degree
  • Expectation: The R5 Switch (22,5 degree) with the supplied short R5 curve piece (7,5 degree) totals 30 degree, thus matching 2 standard R5 curves.

Reality = Not matching ⚠️, the R5 Switch falls short compared to the R5 Curve.

PIKO G Scale Track Geometry Switch R5

PIKO G Scale Track Geometry Switch R5


PIKO R7 Curves & Switches

Theory:

  • PIKO Standard R7 Curve (#35217) = 15 degree angle (24 pcs make a circle)
  • PIKO Short R7 Curve (#35218) = 7,5 degree angle
  • PIKO R7 Switch (#35226 / #35227) = 22,5 degree angle + short R7 curve 7,5 degree
  • Expectation: The R7 Switch (22,5 degree) with the supplied short R7 curve piece (7,5 degree) totals 30 degree, thus matching 2 standard R7 curves.

Reality = Perfect match! ✅

PIKO G Scale Track Geometry Switch R7

PIKO G Scale Track Geometry Switch R7


Conclusion

Well, that’s confusing. While the R1 and R7 curves and switches perfectly line up, the R3 and R5 do not. The rails line up along the curve so the radius matches, but the ends are just too long (R3) or too short (R5) so they are not exactly 30 degrees as advertised.